Buffy: S05E09 – Listening To Fear

"Listening to Fear" stands out as an episode that shatters preconceived notions. It masterfully mixes elements—ranging from heartfelt family interactions to Creepshow-inspired aliens, and unexpected turns that advance the season's overarching plot. This episode serves as a hallmark of the show's capacity to tackle significant real-world themes while maintaining its unique identity and keeping the audience engrossed. That said, the Big Bad in this episode is unsettling enough to discourage me from revisiting it. Rest assured, I won't be sharing any images of that.

Dawn's Identity and Joyce’s Unconditional Love

One of the episode's most poignant aspects is the portrayal of Buffy and Dawn’s care; despite Joyce’s disorienting mental state and personal attacks, Buffy and Dawn offer her unwavering dignity and love. This is particularly touching for anyone who has witnessed or experienced the heartbreaking descent of a loved one into illness.

Before going in for prep, Joyce, due to the pressure from her brain tumor, begins to act erratically and experience hallucinations. Strangely enough, her condition also allows her to see the truth about Dawn. She extracts a promise from Buffy that she will look after Dawn if anything happens to her during her surgery. Buffy confesses, admitting that Dawn isn't really Joyce's daughter, but assures her that she will protect Dawn no matter what. This dialogue sparked an interesting thought: what if Buffy is, in a sense, Dawn's mother? Buffy has been treating Dawn in a maternal manner, saying, "She's not mine, but she is ours." As Joyce unconditionally accepts Dawn, we are reminded of the powerful love a mother can provide, even while dealing with her own severe health issues. And how exactly did they 'make' Dawn?

TarasConstellationChart.com

Adding a softer touch to the dark motifs is the roof scene between Willow and Tara. It might make it a future non-skip for me; honestly. Their stargazing scene and the constellation game add warmth and sweetness, making Tara’s comforting response to Willow’s worries about falling stars an especially memorable moment. Tara’s perfect queer GF response to Willow spiraling over falling stars, ‘what’s wrong babe,” was so well done.The charm of their interactions is a missed opportunity for merchandising Tara’s constellations—there’s a certain whimsy there that fans would surely appreciate. Twillow also witness a meteor crashing near Sunnydale and soon find out that it's no ordinary space rock; it's actually a demon called Queller that has landed on Earth.

Riley’s Dangerous Turn

While the Summers women grapple with Joyce’s illness, Riley, is spiraling in his own dark path. Late to respond to the Scoobys his interaction with vampires becomes not just dangerous but deeply unsettling, turning him into a ticking time bomb. Not to kink shame but his goth phase has taken a turn, and maybe touching base with the initiative will get him back on track. His newfound penchant for danger risks not just his life but the trust and integrity of his relationship with Buffy who cannot approve of this.. heavy handed metaphor for heroin? Adrenaline seeking? Emo goth blood-play? This has gone too far

Willow’s Stakes Two

Willow's triumphant battle against two (buff!) vampires is a highlight that celebrates her journey towards becoming more courageous and independent. Somewhere Riley just got more insecure. It serves as a counterpoint to the darker plots within the episode.

Classic Horror Elements

The tension rises when the Queller demon makes its way to Joyce's home. Buffy springs into action, engaging in a fierce battle with the demon to protect both her mother and sister with yet another assist from Spike. Another impressive factor is how the episode introduces the Queller demon. The creature evokes classic horror vibes akin to The X-Files and several 80s B flicks, thereby elevating the episode's scare factor. Figuring that.. thing.. out was the most confusing kind of horror. We were also left with tantalizing questions about Ben’s role and his connection to the malevolent Glory.

Personal Resonance

On a personal note, "Listening to Fear" tackles the subject of illness and loss in a manner that’s deeply resonant for those who have experienced such challenges. It may be emotionally taxing to address these themes, but the episode does so with grace, giving comfort that these grim experiences are survivable.